Peanut butter sits in almost every kitchen pantry, but not all jars are created equal. Many popular brands pack their spreads with added sugars, unhealthy oils, and artificial ingredients that can harm your health. Finding truly clean peanut butter means looking for simple ingredient lists with minimal processing. Here are sixteen brands that keep it simple and nutritious.
Adams 100% Natural Peanut Butter
Pure peanuts and salt make up this classic spread that has been trusted for generations. Adams refuses to add unnecessary oils or sweeteners to their recipe.
You will need to stir the natural oil separation, but this simple step ensures you are getting authentic peanut flavor. The texture stays creamy without artificial stabilizers that many other brands rely on heavily.
Crazy Richard’s Natural Peanut Butter
Nothing but peanuts goes into every jar of this family-owned company’s signature product. Crazy Richard started making peanut butter in his garage with a simple philosophy about keeping ingredients honest.
The smooth consistency comes from careful grinding techniques rather than added emulsifiers. Kids love the rich taste that comes from using only high-quality Valencia peanuts grown specifically for optimal flavor.
Smucker’s Natural Peanut Butter
Two ingredients tell the whole story: peanuts and a pinch of salt for enhanced flavor. Smucker’s natural line strips away all the extras found in their regular varieties.
The brand sources peanuts from American farms that follow sustainable growing practices. Spreading becomes easier when you store the jar upside down occasionally, allowing natural oils to redistribute throughout the creamy mixture.
Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter
Boston-made since 1925, Teddie grinds fresh peanuts daily without adding palm oil or corn syrup. Their old-fashioned approach creates a distinctly nutty flavor that stands out from mass-produced alternatives.
The company still uses traditional grinding stones that create the perfect texture naturally. Many families have passed down their love for this brand through multiple generations of peanut butter and jelly sandwiches.
MaraNatha Organic No Stir Peanut Butter
Organic peanuts get transformed into spreadable perfection without requiring the usual stirring step. MaraNatha achieves this consistency using natural palm oil instead of hydrogenated alternatives.
The USDA organic certification ensures peanuts grow without synthetic pesticides or fertilizers. Busy parents appreciate the convenience of grab-and-go spreading while maintaining their commitment to feeding families wholesome ingredients that support better health.
Santa Cruz Organic Peanut Butter
California sunshine helps grow the organic peanuts that become this creamy spread with absolutely no added sugar. Santa Cruz maintains strict quality standards throughout their entire production process.
The dark roasted variety offers deeper flavor notes that pair beautifully with apple slices or whole grain toast. Glass jars keep the peanut butter fresh longer while avoiding potential chemical leaching from plastic containers.
365 Whole Foods Organic Peanut Butter
Whole Foods’ house brand delivers organic quality at budget-friendly prices that make healthy eating accessible. The ingredient list stays refreshingly short with just organic peanuts and sea salt.
Bulk purchasing power allows the company to offer premium organic ingredients without premium pricing. The smooth texture spreads easily straight from the jar, making school lunch preparation quick and stress-free for busy mornings.
Justin’s Classic Almond Butter
Dry-roasted almonds create this protein-rich alternative that provides different nutrients than traditional peanut varieties. Justin started his company after struggling to find truly natural nut butters in stores.
The grinding process releases natural almond oils that create creamy consistency without artificial help. Vitamin E and healthy fats make this spread a nutritious choice for athletes and health-conscious families seeking variety.
Once Again Nut Butter Peanut Butter
Small-batch production ensures consistent quality in every jar of this artisanal peanut butter. Once Again sources peanuts directly from farmers who use sustainable growing methods.
The company operates as a certified B-Corporation, meaning they meet strict social and environmental standards. Their Valencia peanut variety offers naturally sweet flavor that reduces cravings for artificially sweetened alternatives found in conventional grocery stores.
Kirkland Signature Organic Peanut Butter
Costco’s house brand proves that organic quality does not require expensive pricing when bought in larger quantities. Two simple ingredients create this family-sized jar of wholesome goodness.
The organic certification guarantees peanuts grow without harmful chemicals that can accumulate in soil over time. Bulk buying reduces packaging waste while providing enough peanut butter to last families several months of regular consumption.
Trader Joe’s Organic Peanut Butter
Affordable organic options make healthy eating accessible through Trader Joe’s commitment to quality private-label products. The creamy texture satisfies without requiring added stabilizers or emulsifiers.
Peanuts and salt create the complete ingredient list for this customer favorite. The distinctive packaging makes it easy to spot on crowded pantry shelves, while the reasonable price point encourages families to choose organic options.
Skippy Natural Peanut Butter
Even mainstream brands now offer cleaner alternatives, with Skippy’s natural line containing just peanuts, sugar, palm oil, and salt. The familiar brand name provides comfort for families transitioning away from heavily processed options.
Natural palm oil replaces hydrogenated oils found in regular Skippy varieties. The slightly sweet taste appeals to children while still maintaining better nutritional profiles than conventional peanut butter options.
Jif Natural Peanut Butter
America’s favorite peanut butter brand offers a natural version with reduced ingredients for health-conscious consumers. Palm oil provides stability without requiring hydrogenation processes that create harmful trans fats.
The familiar Jif taste remains largely unchanged despite removing artificial preservatives and corn syrup. Many families appreciate having a bridge product that helps children adjust to healthier options without completely changing beloved flavors.
Whole Foods 365 Crunchy Peanut Butter
Peanut pieces add delightful texture to this organic spread that contains no added sugars or artificial ingredients. The crunchy variety provides satisfying bites that make snacking more enjoyable.
Organic farming practices ensure peanuts grow in healthy soil without synthetic chemicals. The chunky texture works perfectly for baking applications where extra peanut pieces enhance cookies and energy bars with additional protein and healthy fats.
Laura Scudder’s All Natural Peanut Butter
California-made since 1926, Laura Scudder’s maintains traditional recipes that prioritize simple ingredients over shelf stability. Fresh-ground peanuts create rich flavor that develops during careful roasting processes.
The company refuses to add stabilizers, choosing instead to let natural oil separation occur. Old-fashioned glass jars preserve freshness while reflecting the brand’s commitment to time-tested methods that produce superior taste and nutritional value.
PB2 Powdered Peanut Butter
Innovative processing removes most oils from peanuts, creating a powder that reduces calories while maintaining protein content. Adding water reconstitutes the powder into spreadable consistency when desired.
The lower fat content appeals to people watching caloric intake without giving up peanut flavor entirely. Powdered form offers versatility for smoothies, baking, and cooking applications where traditional peanut butter might be too heavy or calorie-dense.
Leave a comment