Ever wonder what happens when candy makers get a little too bold in the flavor lab? Peeps has made some head-scratching choices. They are funny, but they still end up on store shelves. If you think you’ve tasted them all, meet the marshmallow that tastes like a pickle or something entirely questionable—it depends on your choice.
Hot Tamales Fierce Cinnamon
Ever bite into something expecting sweet and get scorched instead? One of those cinnamon-spiked marshmallows delivers exactly that surprise. Released in 2020, the brand teamed up with Hot Tamales to burn your expectations. You’ll either love the zing or instantly regret the first fiery chew. Dare to try it?
Fruit Punch
Since 2017, Walmart’s exclusive Fruit Punch has brought a tropical, Kool-Aid-style kick to the lineup. Bright red and boldly flavored, the punchy version broke from traditional pastels and pastel taste. For anyone craving candy that tastes like a juice box, this option is a jackpot.
Sour Watermelon
Picture a summer picnic. Now imagine your dessert puckers, your lips. Sour Watermelon Peeps pull a prank on the tongue with a pink interior and green exterior to match the fruit. Originally a seasonal twist, they’ve stuck around thanks to fans who clearly enjoy a good zing with their squish.
Birthday Cake
Birthday Cake Peeps capture the essence of a celebration in every piece. Launched in 2013, they use artificial compounds like ethyl vanillin to recreate the sweet notes of vanilla frosting and confetti cake, appealing to both kids and nostalgic adults chasing a party-like snack experience.
Root Beer Float
Root beer flavor. Soft, chewy texture. It shouldn’t work, but it kinda does. This fizzy-inspired treat hits through cream-soda undertones and a sweet, airy finish. Each bite feels like a flashback wrapped in curiosity. It’s weird and authentic if you’re willing to experiment.
Cotton Candy
Cotton Candy captures the spirit of the fair with its spun sugar notes and colorful speckles. Made to avoid the mess of the real thing, the fluffy option offers a soft and sweet experience that appeals to anyone craving a familiar snack without the stickiness.
Dr Pepper
The brain braces for bubbles, but the soft bite delivers something entirely different. The clash between expectation and reality creates a quick jolt of surprise when you taste Dr Pepper. Made for soda superfans and curious snackers alike, it’s a quirky flavor that plays with perception.
Chocolate Pudding
Tradition gets flipped with a rich, custard-kissed cocoa twist that stands out from typical sugary options. First seen around Easter 2019, the smooth creation skips the usual toppings and draws in dessert fans seeking a gentler, more mellow take on classic chocolate.
Blue Raspberry
Blue Raspberry breaks the rules with a sour kick and a candy-sweet finish. Its unusual color traces back to a clever lab creation from the 1950s, and the Icee collaboration took it up a notch—crafting a fluffy confection which thrills snackers who enjoy something a little unexpected.
Vanilla Creme
Simple doesn’t mean boring. Vanilla Creme delivers a smooth, melt-in-your-mouth experience with hints of white chocolate and whipped icing. These marshmallows favor elegance over gimmicks, offering a gentle flavor that satisfies without overwhelming—perfect for those who appreciate a softer, more refined take on sugary indulgence.
Leave a comment