They smelled like melted cheese and arcade tokens. For many, these spots defined Friday nights and birthday parties. However, while the memories linger, most of these pizza joints have since disappeared or are slowly fading away into oblivion. What happened to these booths? Let’s rewind the decade and examine what vanished when no one was looking.
ShowBiz Pizza Place
Those clunky animatronic bears? Terrifying or awesome, depending on your age. ShowBiz Pizza nailed the pizza-party formula. However, high costs and a merger with Chuck E. Cheese killed the concept. The Rock-afire Explosion lives on only in retro YouTube videos and collector nostalgia.
Pietro’s Pizza
Only a few remain today, a nostalgic blip for those who remember the days of big booths and pizza night traditions. Pietro’s once thrived in Oregon and Washington, with wood salad bars and classic wood paneling drawing in families. As competitors modernized, Pietro’s footprint shrank dramatically.
Pizza Haven
Using Jeeps and pickup trucks, Pizza Haven delivered pizza across Seattle in any way it could. It helped shape early delivery culture and stood out for its hustle. However, by the ’90s, legal troubles and mounting debt brought it down quickly. Now, it’s barely a footnote in pizza history.
The Brothers Three
Started by three brothers (yes, really), this Wisconsin mini-chain felt like someone turned a rec room into a restaurant. While it earned love from the ardent local fans, expansion wasn’t in the cards. One remains in Marinette. The rest? Quietly gone.
Cap’n Galley’s Pizza & Pipes
Which pizza joint had full pipe organ concerts? Cap’n Galley’s! They delivered family meals and live music. The spectacle charmed guests, but high maintenance and limited appeal made survival tough. Eventually, the music stopped, and so did the chain.
Pizza Corner
Pizza Corner’s frozen pies still sit in grocery stores, but the dine-in restaurants that inspired them have vanished, except the original one in Valley City, North Dakota. For others, the name now triggers memories in freezer aisles, not neon-lit storefronts or buzzing dinnertime crowds.
Pizza Time Theater
Arcade machines and pizza! Pizza Time Theater combined them all in one ambitious idea, courtesy of Atari’s founder. Sadly, what began boldly in the ’80s vanished just as quickly. Financial trouble hit them fast by forcing a merger with ShowBiz. The name disappeared soon after.
Godfather’s Pizza
Famous for their thick crust and bold branding, Godfather’s thrived in the ’80s. At its peak, the place had over 1,000 locations nationwide. However, competition from delivery giants and internal struggles led to significant downsizing. Some franchises still operate, though their national footprint has shrunk dramatically.
EATZA Pizza
This all-you-can-eat buffet chain was a big deal in the ’90s and early 2000s. EATZA Pizza piled high with options—from mac’ n’ cheese slices to dessert pies. But the rise of fast-casual and quality-over-quantity dining knocked it out. Most locations vanished, leaving behind only melted cheese memories.
Noble Roman’s
It is an Indiana-based pizza franchise that caught the attention of casual diners across the Midwest in the 1980s. Poor franchisee support and overexpansion led to a decline in the joint’s performance. Today, they operate under the rebranded Craft Pizza & Pub concept in Indiana, utilizing a combination of corporate and franchise management.
Leave a comment